Concierge
A form of MVP where on the user's side things seem automated whereas behind the scenes they are solved with manual labour.
What is Concierge?
The Concierge MVP is a powerful validation technique where startups provide their core service manually while presenting a polished, seemingly automated experience to users. This approach allows entrepreneurs to test their value proposition, understand user needs, and refine their solution before investing in expensive technology infrastructure. The beauty of the concierge method lies in its ability to deliver real value to customers while gathering authentic behavioral data and feedback.
Unlike other validation techniques that rely on hypothetical scenarios or prototypes, the concierge MVP involves actually delivering the promised service through human intervention. This creates genuine customer relationships and provides deep insights into user workflows, pain points, and feature priorities. By manually fulfilling requests behind the scenes, founders can iterate quickly on their service delivery, pricing models, and user experience without the constraints of technical limitations or development timelines.
When to Use This Experiment
• Early-stage startups testing complex service ideas that would require significant technical investment to automate • B2B solutions where the core value proposition involves data processing, analysis, or consultation services • Marketplace or matching services before building sophisticated algorithms or recommendation engines • When technical feasibility is uncertain but you want to validate market demand and willingness to pay • Service-based businesses that could eventually be automated through software or AI • Complex workflow solutions where you need to understand the optimal user journey before coding • Industries with high compliance or quality requirements where manual oversight might always be necessary
How to Run This Experiment
-
Define your core value proposition and identify which aspects could theoretically be automated in the future, then determine what you can reasonably deliver manually in the short term.
-
Create a professional front-end interface such as a simple website, landing page, or basic app that allows users to submit requests or access your service in an apparently seamless way.
-
Establish manual fulfillment processes by mapping out internal workflows, assigning team responsibilities, and creating quality standards for service delivery behind the scenes.
-
Launch with a small user base starting with friends, family, or targeted prospects who fit your ideal customer profile to minimize risk and gather initial feedback.
-
Deliver exceptional manual service while carefully documenting user behaviors, common requests, edge cases, and feedback to inform future product development.
-
Track key metrics including user satisfaction, retention rates, time-to-fulfillment, operational costs, and willingness to pay for your manually-delivered service.
-
Iterate and scale gradually by refining your manual processes, identifying automation opportunities, and expanding your user base as you validate product-market fit.
-
Plan your automation roadmap using insights gathered from manual delivery to prioritize features and technical requirements for eventual software development.
Pros and Cons
Pros
• High reliability and accuracy - Human oversight ensures quality service delivery and can handle edge cases that would break automated systems • Deep customer insights - Direct interaction with service fulfillment provides rich understanding of user needs and behaviors • Rapid iteration capability - Changes to service delivery can be implemented immediately without development cycles • Zero technical risk - Validates market demand without upfront technology investment or development complexity • Authentic user experience - Customers receive real value, creating genuine relationships and honest feedback
Cons
• Limited scalability - Manual processes become bottlenecks as user base grows, requiring careful capacity management • Higher operational costs - Labor-intensive delivery may result in unsustainable unit economics compared to automated solutions • Team burnout risk - Intensive manual fulfillment can be exhausting and difficult to maintain long-term • Quality consistency challenges - Human variability may lead to inconsistent service experiences across different team members • Difficulty maintaining the illusion - Users may discover the manual nature of the service, potentially affecting perception
Real-World Examples
Food on the Table started as a concierge service where the founders manually created personalized meal plans and grocery lists for each customer. They would spend hours researching recipes, checking local store prices, and crafting custom recommendations by hand while users experienced a streamlined digital interface. This manual approach helped them understand customer preferences deeply and eventually led to a $8.5 million acquisition by Scripps Networks.
Zapier's early days involved the founders manually connecting apps and transferring data between services for their first users. Instead of building complex integration infrastructure, they would literally copy and paste information between different platforms while users believed their workflows were automated. This concierge approach validated demand for app integrations and informed their eventual automated platform architecture.
Rent the Runway initially operated with a concierge-like model where founders Jennifer Hyman and Jenny Fleiss personally managed the entire rental process. They manually selected dresses, coordinated with designers, handled dry cleaning logistics, and managed customer service for each rental. This hands-on approach taught them about sizing issues, customer preferences, and operational challenges before scaling their automated inventory and logistics systems.